Prompto hadn't even been remotely serious about peanut butter; could you imagine cleaning up after that?? But now he really did need to ask.

"Why would he keep eating it if it was hurting him?" he asked, like someone who definitely knew nothing about anything like that, honest! Well, he didn't! Because repression! "Also, you can know he wants all this fancy-ass stuff for his party, but not know whether he's allergic to peanut butter or not?"